Optical (Blu-ray/DVD) and Digital (EST/UV) Sales Thread

[PSound]

POTC week with the Blu-ray exclusive release.

$61 million for all of Blu-ray that week.

[PSound]

I was thinking about $30 million and you were thinking about $35.

All of Blu-ray did $61 million, which is VERY low based on back of the napkin projections I saw.



What is interesting is that OD as a whole as up 9.47% If Disney would have done a typical release, the week would have probably been one of the strongest YoY weeks for OD this year.

What was the comparison like last year (box office lead-in)?

[bruceames]

Wow, $61 million is really bad considering Pirates was Blu-ray exclusive. I would have thought $80 disappointing as well.

[bruceames]

Originally Posted by PSound

I was thinking about $30 million and you were thinking about $35.

All of Blu-ray did $61 million, which is VERY low based on back of the napkin projections I saw.



What is interesting is that OD as a whole as up 9.47% If Disney would have done a typical release, the week would have probably been one of the strongest YoY weeks for OD this year.

What was the comparison like last year (box office lead-in)?

Yeah, it probably was more like $30 for Pirates and $31 for everything else (maybe even less than $30 for Pirates).

Of course, The-Numbers is going to report a huge week and be close to $100 million for the top 10. What a joke.

[PSound]

Originally Posted by bruceames

Yeah, it probably was more like $30 for Pirates and $31 for everything else (maybe even less than $30 for Pirates).

Of course, The-Numbers is going to report a huge week and be close to $100 million for the top 10. What a joke.

The-Numbers is a joke. It should be obvious by now.

[bruceames]

Originally Posted by PSound

What was the comparison like last year (box office lead-in)?

Last year was crap by comparison. Only $56 million among 2 titles. POTC4 week was $373 million. So you have nearly a 7:1 ratio of box office power in your favor, PLUS Pirates 4 exclusive to Blu-ray, and YoY is up only 120%. I honestly thought it would be up at least 300%.

[bruceames]

OD up 9.47% is not impressive at all considering YoY box office power.

[PSound]

Originally Posted by bruceames

Last year was crap by comparison. Only $56 million among 2 titles. POTC4 week was $373 million. So you have nearly a 7:1 ratio of box office power in your favor, PLUS Pirates 4 exclusive to Blu-ray, and YoY is up only 120%. I honestly thought it would be up at least 300%.

Thanks for the info.

With that kind of box office disparity, OD performance was VERY weak.

My guess is this week would have been way more impressive with a DVD release.


We will have to wait to see if the DVD sells in a few weeks, but right now it didn't really do much to spur Blu-ray sales. I think it is safe to say the consumer has spoken and said it is too soon to try and go BD only.

[bruceames]

Originally Posted by PSound

Thanks for the info.

With that kind of box office disparity, OD performance was VERY weak.

My guess is this week would have been way more impressive with a DVD release.


We will have to wait to see if the DVD sells in a few weeks, but right now it didn't really do much to spur Blu-ray sales. I think it is safe to say the consumer has spoken and said it is too soon to try and go BD only.

Yes, the BD exclusivity really hurt OD. It may catch up some when the DVD gets released next month though. Although it'll be impossible to know by how much unless Disney releases sales figures, which is unlikely.

[PSound]

Originally Posted by bruceames

Yes, the BD exclusivity really hurt OD. It may catch up some when the DVD gets released next month though. Although it'll be impossible to know by how much unless Disney releases sales figures, which is unlikely.

This was significant enough that it may get asked during their Q4 earnings call.

I know Toy Story 3 was discussed much last year, particularly how poor the conversion rate was compared to what OD did 3 years ago. If this experiment results in a significant decline in conversion, it may get discussed.

[chipvideo]

Originally Posted by PSound

This was significant enough that it may get asked during their Q4 earnings call.

I know Toy Story 3 was discussed much last year, particularly how poor the conversion rate was compared to what OD did 3 years ago. If this experiment results in a significant decline in conversion, it may get discussed.

I can't wait to here what Iger has to say. He has to tell it the way it is. No sugar coating.

[PSound]

Originally Posted by chipvideo

I can't wait to here what Iger has to say. He has to tell it the way it is. No sugar coating.

Iger generally has been good about being clear about the issues with Home Video.

He is the one who honestly pointed out the decline in new release performance, calling the decline in conversion rates "sobering".

[bruceames]

Updated thru week ending 10/22/11
Table of Blu-ray sales (HMM and DEG)
numbers are in (revenue) millions.

2011 total  5972.74   -13.3%    4639.84   -20.3%    1332.90   24.6%    22.3%    7199.5  7435.3										
Week Date      OD     OD YoY      DVD    DVD YoY       BD    BD YoY  BD Share  TBO2011 TBO2010										

Q4 total     493.65     5.5%     312.31   -13.5%     181.34   69.2%    36.7%     961.9   546.6

42  10/22    156.94     9.5%      95.94   -17.1%      61.00  120.8%    38.9%     370.0    56.0
41  10/15    152.92    -2.4%     106.50   -14.1%      46.42   42.2%    30.4%     343.3   233.0
40  10/8     183.79     9.3%     109.87    -9.4%      73.92   57.7%    40.2%     248.6   257.6

Q3 DEG      1742.79    -4.0%    1320.93   -14.7%     421.86   58.0%    24.2%
Q3 total    1667.09    -4.9%    1298.39   -13.9%     368.70   49.9%    22.1%    1806.3  1609.5										

39  10/1     152.58   -14.3%     109.97   -20.4%      42.61    7.1%    27.9%     352.1   382.7
38  9/24     153.60     5.0%     108.69   -12.5%      44.91  103.6%    29.2%     169.3   112.5
37  9/17     164.69    14.0%     107.37   -14.2%      57.32  197.2%    34.8%     190.8   165.2
36  9/10     128.84     0.0%     102.29   -10.5%      26.55   82.9%    20.6%     189.3    60.3
35  9/3      119.04    -9.5%     100.87   -13.7%      18.17   23.5%    15.3%      65.6    95.1
34  8/27     109.34   -13.1%      91.74   -16.6%      17.60   11.5%    16.1%      12.6    45.3
33  8/20     124.53    -4.4%     101.11   -12.8%      23.42   63.3%    18.8%     100.8    81.2
32  8/13     122.13    -1.8%      98.44    -9.5%      23.69   51.8%    19.4%     118.0   143.9
31  8/6      139.66     1.4%     111.78    -3.6%      27.88   27.9%    20.0%     189.8   133.5
30  7/30     108.78   -18.3%      89.06   -20.2%      19.72   -8.7%    18.1%      56.8   177.2
29  7/23     120.50    -1.9%      97.25    -9.4%      23.25   49.9%    19.3%      88.3    72.7
28  7/16     118.09    -4.8%      94.88   -13.5%      23.21   61.7%    19.7%     267.8    94.7
27  7/9      105.31   -16.7%      84.94   -22.7%      20.37   22.9%    19.3%       5.1    45.2										
		
Q2 DEG      1831      -15.0%    1434      -18.8%     397       9.4%    21.7%
Q2 total    1791.55   -12.2%    1402.94   -16.7%     388.61    9.1%    21.7%    2314.8  2422.0

26  7/2      127.11   -12.3%      96.32   -21.6%      30.79   39.4%    24.2%     102.3   181.4
25  6/25     123.25    -7.7%      98.18   -12.8%      25.07   20.1%    20.3%     205.4    85.8
24  6/18     149.89   -11.2%     114.68   -17.7%      35.21   19.5%    23.5%     208.2   142.8
23  6/11     130.81   -13.6%     103.23   -18.6%      27.58   12.3%    21.1%     305.0   152.6
22  6/4      118.16   -34.1%      96.17   -32.8%      21.99  -39.1%    18.6%      15.8   386.8
21  5/28     113.83   -16.6%      91.37   -22.9%      22.46   24.9%    19.7%     154.4    87.9
20  5/21     111.98   -15.2%      91.84   -18.9%      20.14    7.2%    18.0%      99.8   185.7
19  5/14     111.02   -23.6%      90.00   -26.8%      21.02   -6.2%    18.9%     155.6   113.6
18  5/7      122.05   -25.2%      99.74   -29.5%      22.31   -7.7%    18.3%     141.5   106.1
17  4/30     106.99   -40.6%      86.94   -39.6%      20.05  -44.5%    18.7%       0.0   120.5
16  4/23     217.30    -8.3%     171.47    -0.3%      45.83  -29.4%    21.1%     187.5   841.3
15  4/16     184.50    48.7%     134.40    24.8%      50.10  205.3%    27.2%     314.8     8.1
14  4/9      174.66    21.6%     128.60     5.9%      46.06  107.5%    26.5%     424.5     9.4
										
Q1 DEG      2068      -20.0%    1661      -25.0%     407      10.0%    19.7%		
Q1 total    2020.45   -23.2%    1626.20   -28.4%     394.25    9.4%    19.5%    2116.5  2857.2

13  4/2      192.11   -36.0%     144.16   -44.6%      47.95   20.1%    25.0%     300.9   461.1
12  3/26     135.54   -49.8%     110.21   -50.9%      25.33  -44.1%    18.7%     218.0   335.6
11  3/19     138.72   -46.5%     112.58   -49.6%      26.14  -27.1%    18.8%     154.2   534.3
10  3/12     146.96   -24.4%     116.11   -30.8%      30.85   16.5%    21.0%     177.0   247.2
9   3/5      174.59    -7.2%     132.93   -15.4%      41.66   34.1%    23.9%     112.3   258.8
8   2/26     160.96     4.5%     130.35    -2.5%      30.61   50.7%    19.0%     258.0    74.9
7   2/19     172.68    -8.1%     143.99   -12.7%      28.69   25.0%    16.6%      86.2    80.1
6   2/12     172.00   -19.4%     145.34   -23.1%      26.66    8.9%    15.5%     224.0   211.0
5   2/5      158.26   -16.7%     131.08   -20.8%      27.18   11.1%    17.2%      23.0   114.6
4   1/29     151.21   -14.6%     122.05   -20.9%      29.16   27.6%    19.3%     201.2   151.6
3   1/22     131.62   -16.3%     107.98   -21.0%      23.64   14.8%    18.0%      60.7    61.0
2   1/15     135.49   -17.3%     108.51   -23.9%      26.98   27.0%    19.9%     143.3   137.8
1   1/8      150.31   -14.1%     120.91   -19.5%      29.40   18.6%    19.6%     157.7   189.2

OD = optical disc (DVD + Blu-ray)
YoY = year over year percentage change
TBO = total box office
BD = Blu-ray

[PSound]

Originally Posted by bruceames

Updated thru week ending 10/22/11
Table of Blu-ray sales (HMM and DEG)
numbers are in (revenue) millions.

2011 total  5972.74   -13.3%    4639.84   -20.3%    1332.90   24.6%    22.3%    7199.5  7435.3										
Week Date      OD     OD YoY      DVD    DVD YoY       BD    BD YoY  BD Share  TBO2011 TBO2010										

Q4 total     493.65     5.5%     312.31   -13.5%     181.34   69.2%    36.7%     961.9   546.6

42  10/22    156.94     9.5%      95.94   -17.1%      61.00  120.8%    38.9%     370.0    56.0
41  10/15    152.92    -2.4%     106.50   -14.1%      46.42   42.2%    30.4%     343.3   233.0
40  10/8     183.79     9.3%     109.87    -9.4%      73.92   57.7%    40.2%     248.6   257.6

Q3 DEG      1742.79    -4.0%    1320.93   -14.7%     421.86   58.0%    24.2%
Q3 total    1667.09    -4.9%    1298.39   -13.9%     368.70   49.9%    22.1%    1806.3  1609.5										

39  10/1     152.58   -14.3%     109.97   -20.4%      42.61    7.1%    27.9%     352.1   382.7
38  9/24     153.60     5.0%     108.69   -12.5%      44.91  103.6%    29.2%     169.3   112.5
37  9/17     164.69    14.0%     107.37   -14.2%      57.32  197.2%    34.8%     190.8   165.2
36  9/10     128.84     0.0%     102.29   -10.5%      26.55   82.9%    20.6%     189.3    60.3
35  9/3      119.04    -9.5%     100.87   -13.7%      18.17   23.5%    15.3%      65.6    95.1
34  8/27     109.34   -13.1%      91.74   -16.6%      17.60   11.5%    16.1%      12.6    45.3
33  8/20     124.53    -4.4%     101.11   -12.8%      23.42   63.3%    18.8%     100.8    81.2
32  8/13     122.13    -1.8%      98.44    -9.5%      23.69   51.8%    19.4%     118.0   143.9
31  8/6      139.66     1.4%     111.78    -3.6%      27.88   27.9%    20.0%     189.8   133.5
30  7/30     108.78   -18.3%      89.06   -20.2%      19.72   -8.7%    18.1%      56.8   177.2
29  7/23     120.50    -1.9%      97.25    -9.4%      23.25   49.9%    19.3%      88.3    72.7
28  7/16     118.09    -4.8%      94.88   -13.5%      23.21   61.7%    19.7%     267.8    94.7
27  7/9      105.31   -16.7%      84.94   -22.7%      20.37   22.9%    19.3%       5.1    45.2										
		
Q2 DEG      1831      -15.0%    1434      -18.8%     397       9.4%    21.7%
Q2 total    1791.55   -12.2%    1402.94   -16.7%     388.61    9.1%    21.7%    2314.8  2422.0

26  7/2      127.11   -12.3%      96.32   -21.6%      30.79   39.4%    24.2%     102.3   181.4
25  6/25     123.25    -7.7%      98.18   -12.8%      25.07   20.1%    20.3%     205.4    85.8
24  6/18     149.89   -11.2%     114.68   -17.7%      35.21   19.5%    23.5%     208.2   142.8
23  6/11     130.81   -13.6%     103.23   -18.6%      27.58   12.3%    21.1%     305.0   152.6
22  6/4      118.16   -34.1%      96.17   -32.8%      21.99  -39.1%    18.6%      15.8   386.8
21  5/28     113.83   -16.6%      91.37   -22.9%      22.46   24.9%    19.7%     154.4    87.9
20  5/21     111.98   -15.2%      91.84   -18.9%      20.14    7.2%    18.0%      99.8   185.7
19  5/14     111.02   -23.6%      90.00   -26.8%      21.02   -6.2%    18.9%     155.6   113.6
18  5/7      122.05   -25.2%      99.74   -29.5%      22.31   -7.7%    18.3%     141.5   106.1
17  4/30     106.99   -40.6%      86.94   -39.6%      20.05  -44.5%    18.7%       0.0   120.5
16  4/23     217.30    -8.3%     171.47    -0.3%      45.83  -29.4%    21.1%     187.5   841.3
15  4/16     184.50    48.7%     134.40    24.8%      50.10  205.3%    27.2%     314.8     8.1
14  4/9      174.66    21.6%     128.60     5.9%      46.06  107.5%    26.5%     424.5     9.4
										
Q1 DEG      2068      -20.0%    1661      -25.0%     407      10.0%    19.7%		
Q1 total    2020.45   -23.2%    1626.20   -28.4%     394.25    9.4%    19.5%    2116.5  2857.2

13  4/2      192.11   -36.0%     144.16   -44.6%      47.95   20.1%    25.0%     300.9   461.1
12  3/26     135.54   -49.8%     110.21   -50.9%      25.33  -44.1%    18.7%     218.0   335.6
11  3/19     138.72   -46.5%     112.58   -49.6%      26.14  -27.1%    18.8%     154.2   534.3
10  3/12     146.96   -24.4%     116.11   -30.8%      30.85   16.5%    21.0%     177.0   247.2
9   3/5      174.59    -7.2%     132.93   -15.4%      41.66   34.1%    23.9%     112.3   258.8
8   2/26     160.96     4.5%     130.35    -2.5%      30.61   50.7%    19.0%     258.0    74.9
7   2/19     172.68    -8.1%     143.99   -12.7%      28.69   25.0%    16.6%      86.2    80.1
6   2/12     172.00   -19.4%     145.34   -23.1%      26.66    8.9%    15.5%     224.0   211.0
5   2/5      158.26   -16.7%     131.08   -20.8%      27.18   11.1%    17.2%      23.0   114.6
4   1/29     151.21   -14.6%     122.05   -20.9%      29.16   27.6%    19.3%     201.2   151.6
3   1/22     131.62   -16.3%     107.98   -21.0%      23.64   14.8%    18.0%      60.7    61.0
2   1/15     135.49   -17.3%     108.51   -23.9%      26.98   27.0%    19.9%     143.3   137.8
1   1/8      150.31   -14.1%     120.91   -19.5%      29.40   18.6%    19.6%     157.7   189.2

OD = optical disc (DVD + Blu-ray)
YoY = year over year percentage change
TBO = total box office
BD = Blu-ray

That gap in Q4 box office is amazing!

2011 - 961.9 2010 - 546.6

[bruceames]

Originally Posted by chipvideo

I can't wait to here what Iger has to say. He has to tell it the way it is. No sugar coating.

Blu-ray obviously wasn't up to the task of carrying a mediocre title exclusively, and one that's priced at $23-25 to boot. POTC4 is no Lion King, and consumers in general will only go above the $20 threshold if it's a really good movie. POTC4 doesn't qualify. They would have had more success with Cars 2, even though that's by far the worst Pixar movie ever made. They also should have had it at an SRP so it could have been street priced at under $20.

So I think a big part of the problem is that Disney's releasing some big duds this fall, and it's not all Blu-ray's (or DVD's) fault.