Why are you getting or did you get a PS3 over a 360?

mshulman · 12-10-2006, 12:17 PM

I'm curious about this and haven't really gotten any replies when I've approached the subject in other threads.

So.. If you are only buying 1 console, why did you choose the PS3? I'd also be interested in those that have sold 360's to get a PS3.

All I see for advantages are: Bluray or compatibility with PS2 games/accessories.

Other than that, I think 360 offers everything else, PLUS great online gaming. Maybe PS3 owners don't rank online play as high as I do??

Type A · 12-10-2006, 12:26 PM

LOL, wrong forum dude...try this one:

http://www.ps3forums.com/

Sorry, I know its a smart ass remark, but couldnt resist...and I think this forum is just a little pro-M$

mshulman · 12-10-2006, 01:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Type A

LOL, wrong forum dude...try this one:

http://www.ps3forums.com/

Sorry, I know its a smart ass remark, but couldnt resist...and I think this forum is just a little pro-M$

I have tried at the main playstation forums on Sony's site. Boy are they against any posts that mention any other consoles. It seems to me that someone asking "Why should I get a PS3 if I already have a 360" should be answered. Maybe I'd actually get one. But Sony locked my thread very quickly. That answered my question quite easily..

I really would like to know why someone chooses it over the 360 though. All the info I've looke at just shows I mae the right choice with 360 - I am waiting for someone to show me otherwise.

Steve44 · 12-10-2006, 02:20 PM

Personally, I feel both consoles are about the same right now in terms of graphics. I'm only looking for basic online play - both offer that for free.
I want to use a high-definition dvd. Both have that for same price - essentially. However, the PS3 offers HDMI which is a plus (I think) - not a negative (PS3 +0.5)
I owned and loved PS2 games more than Xbox games (GTA is my absolute favorite game ever. (PS3 +1).
I can also play my other PS2 games that I own on my PS3 because I'm not done playing those. Then I can sell my used ps2 for $25 (PS3 +0.5)
I also still feel (or maybe I'm just hopelessly hoping) that the PS3 will only improve. (PS3 +0.5)
I can watch HD video clips from the internet (PS3 +0.5)
HD-DVD may win the format war in a few years and then the BluRay options will decrease (360 +1.0)
I can put music on my PS3 and listen to the music on my surround sound (PS3 +0.5) (I really don't know if 360 can do that - haven't heard about it).

I think there are a few other things, but that's a decent list...
For me PS3 wins by 2.5pts (not much) on my personal weighted scale.

I may be a fanboy now but I wasn't a few months ago. I started with wanting to buy a PS3 and then was going to pick up the 360 for about 2 weeks, but then I decided to stick with the PS3.
Besides, what-ever console I buy will be free because of gift cards and my "SPIFF" money from work.

pjc · 12-10-2006, 03:35 PM

When I get mine, I will get a 360. I was a PS fanboy having the PS1 and PS2. Two of my buddies both got original XBOX's. Wanting to be able to play against them online, I traded my PS2 in for any XBOX (~4-5 years ago.). I have NEVER regretted it. I liked the XBOX much better. I am going to stick with M$ because I liked the original XBOX over the PS2 and the 360 out of the box is cheaper. I know, if you add the 360' HD-DVD drive, their the same price. Well, I may or may upgrade, but I have the choice.

Razor05 · 12-10-2006, 04:04 PM

I think one of the biggest deciding factors is Xbox Live. If you feel that both consoles are about the same, and you love playing online, then the choice is simple. If there is one thing that Sony can't compare to, it would be that.

Steve44 · 12-10-2006, 04:56 PM

Agree, if you want all that in online play.
360 online is far better and I think most will agree. But other than online play, PS3 offers more of what I would use. Basic online play is good enough for me.

bboncorr · 12-10-2006, 05:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steve44

Personally, I feel both consoles are about the same right now in terms of graphics. I'm only looking for basic online play - both offer that for free.
the 360 is getting better reviews across the board from just about every reviewer that isnt connected to sony in the graphics department and smothness of the games. while the ps3 online is free and the 360 is $50 for the year but i would rather pay for such a better online service esp. since it only comes out to be $4.16 and we get game demos and movie previews for free.

I want to use a high-definition dvd. Both have that for same price - essentially. However, the PS3 offers HDMI which is a plus (I think) - not a negative (PS3 +0.5)
only a plus if you need one cable connectivity.

I owned and loved PS2 games more than Xbox games (GTA is my absolute favorite game ever. (PS3 +1).
sony is losing just about all there exclusive titles including gta while ms hasnt been losing there exclusive titles.

I can also play my other PS2 games that I own on my PS3 because I'm not done playing those. Then I can sell my used ps2 for $25 (PS3 +0.5)
same is true for the 360 plus the 360 has less issues with backwards compatibility with xbox games. it is a great plus if there are alot of ps2 games you still want to play if they still work on the ps3.

I also still feel (or maybe I'm just hopelessly hoping) that the PS3 will only improve. (PS3 +0.5)
same is true for the 360. i dont see how both systems wont improve but remember the 360 is gonna improve at a much faster rate due to the year lead, easy of programing, and cost of making games. then lets not forget that ms has allways had much better programs to make games with. programers have allready stated the ps3 will be the port system this time around and its been proven by the launch titles and next wave of games already being confirmed as ports.

I can watch HD video clips from the internet (PS3 +0.5)
you can download movies and tv shows on the 360 for a fee and get movie previews and game demos for free via xbl.

HD-DVD may win the format war in a few years and then the BluRay options will decrease (360 +1.0)
to be honest nobody can predict which format will win at this point. seems like every 6months a media frenzy happens and another company says they will support both very soon. i see either a double format for a long time or a unified format. this would hurt the ps3 more then it would hurt the 360 so sony is trying to avoid this at all cost until there systems become cheaper to make.

I can put music on my PS3 and listen to the music on my surround sound (PS3 +0.5) (I really don't know if 360 can do that - haven't heard about it).
the 360 can do this but it has a very orginized system. you can orginize your music by genre, name of group or artist or album. you can stream music from your pc if you have xp media edition. you can also transfer photos and videos to your 360 from your computer. there is a ton of other stuff you can do but i just use my computer for that stuff so i didnt bother trying to figure it out.

I think there are a few other things, but that's a decent list...
For me PS3 wins by 2.5pts (not much) on my personal weighted scale.

I may be a fanboy now but I wasn't a few months ago. I started with wanting to buy a PS3 and then was going to pick up the 360 for about 2 weeks, but then I decided to stick with the PS3.
Besides, what-ever console I buy will be free because of gift cards and my "SPIFF" money from work.

my answers are in bold above.

pedrohead · 12-10-2006, 05:52 PM

i haven't bought either yet, but am looking into the options.

i have a ps2 (as far as previous console) and really enjoy some of the ps-proprietary games like metal gear, gran turismo, ssx, so that would really steer me toward ps3.

plus it seems like some of the technological advantages of the ps3 (1080p gaming, capabilities for 7 controllers, HDMI ports, built in wireless, 7.1/true-HD sound, etc.) may make it a little more technologically sound and future proof for a few more years.

but i think it may be months (or another year) before it really gets its footing and gets some good games under its belt.

i may be looking at a 360 before that time comes, but i really only want to get one console. i don't play too much (and don't really play online), so i'm keeping my options open.

mshulman · 12-10-2006, 06:07 PM

Good answer - I can accept that

I find it interesting none of the diehards have had anything to say... See some comments I made on your reasons below though..

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steve44

I want to use a high-definition dvd. Both have that for same price - essentially. However, the PS3 offers HDMI which is a plus (I think) - not a negative (PS3 +0.5)

Everything I have heard, seen, read..etc seems to indicate that you will get the very same picture quality from the Xbox HD-DVD add on at 1080i - even on a 1080P TV. Just curious - Is your TV 1080P? If not, then Component would be fine on either. I'm not trying to convince you - just make sure you know the facts.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steve44

I owned and loved PS2 games more than Xbox games (GTA is my absolute favorite game ever. (PS3 +1).

You know the next GTA will be out on the 360, right?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steve44

I can also play my other PS2 games that I own on my PS3 because I'm not done playing those. Then I can sell my used ps2 for $25 (PS3 +0.5)

So many people use this as a reason for one of the other or sticking within a brand. Personally, I feel (especially at $25) that sticking with a brand just for the sake of playing old games limits your choices and should never have any input in a decision. I have both my old Xbox's, but I sold all the games except halo 2. Only reason I kept the consoles is due to the low value of them and the fact I could rent games if I decide I want to play them.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steve44

I also still feel (or maybe I'm just hopelessly hoping) that the PS3 will only improve. (PS3 +0.5)

Again, not trying to convince, but as long as you are scoring on this, wouldn't you say 360 would improve? I think it already has since launch. And I am sure the PS3 will improve... how much is my only concern

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steve44

I can watch HD video clips from the internet (PS3 +0.5)

I assume this is because of the internet browser?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steve44

HD-DVD may win the format war in a few years and then the BluRay options will decrease (360 +1.0)

Just to be consistently fair, bluray would still be able to play any bluray titles you bought, plus games. In addition, its very likley that both formats could be around until the next consoles come out!

Quote:

Originally Posted by steve44

I can put music on my PS3 and listen to the music on my surround sound (PS3 +0.5) (I really don't know if 360 can do that - haven't heard about it).

Ah.. you haven't done your homework

This is exactly why I question PS3 buyers. 360 has been around for a year. There are more games and there have been numerous additional features added since the release. One feature its always had is being able to play music. There are many ways to do this - Plug in an ipod, plug in a USB drive with mp3's on it, throw in a cd and rip it, or if you have a media center PC, stream things from it. This is also possible from any XP system using an add on software that will allow you to share music. Plus, all of the above I mentioned also supports photos and videos.

Thanks for the response - I think many people are in your shoes and to some degree aren't even aware of all the capabilities of the 360. I think I'll have to make a list, then we can compare and see what the PS3 has, doesn't have or has that the 360 doesn't

For what its worth, with everything you listed, buying today, there's really no true right or wrong choice. I just feel you could have bought 6 months ago and had the same things

And if online gaming isn't a big concern, then the major feature I see lacking from PS3 wouldn't matter to you anyway.

hmm.. speaking of online gaming, wouldn't it be great to be able to game online with people between different consoles?

mshulman · 12-10-2006, 06:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bboncorr

Quote:

Originally Posted by steve44

I can also play my other PS2 games that I own on my PS3 because I'm not done playing those. Then I can sell my used ps2 for $25 (PS3 +0.5)

same is true for the 360 plus the 360 has less issues with backwards compatibility with xbox games. it is a great plus if there are alot of ps2 games you still want to play if they still work on the ps3.

Just to be fair, the 360 has very limited backwards compatibility and they aren't adding any more titles. I think PS2's backwards compatibility is probably better - only 200 titles (last I heard) had issues.

Regardless, considering trading in an old console won't even get you a new game, I can't understand why so many people consider this.

bboncorr · 12-10-2006, 06:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pedrohead

plus it seems like some of the technological advantages of the ps3 (1080p gaming, capabilities for 7 controllers, HDMI ports, built in wireless, 7.1/true-HD sound, etc.) may make it a little more technologically sound and future proof for a few more years.

.

i dont know what the advantages are here that you are talking about.

1080p is available on both systems. you do know that developers are saying that 1080p will not be a big option in this gen or atleast for a long time. sony games are chugging at 720p never mind 1080p.

true-hd sound is available on both systems. ms will be releasing a hdmi soon based on there recent update so that wont be a advantage either. component will give you the same quality video as hdmi so dont buy into the hype.

how often are you gonna have over 7 friends to play games. if your in college or still young then i can see why its a great thing but i doubt it will be used to often if at all.

i do with my 360 was online wireless for free though.

bboncorr · 12-10-2006, 06:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mshulman

Just to be fair, the 360 has very limited backwards compatibility and they aren't adding any more titles. I think PS2's backwards compatibility is probably better - only 200 titles (last I heard) had issues.

Regardless, considering trading in an old console won't even get you a new game, I can't understand why so many people consider this.

very true on all comments you posted. i was in a rush and should have waited to post so i could have been more accurate and informitive with that post.

mshulman · 12-10-2006, 06:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pedrohead

i have a ps2 (as far as previous console) and really enjoy some of the ps-proprietary games like metal gear, gran turismo, ssx, so that would really steer me toward ps3.

If exclusives are must haves for you (NOTE: If PS3 had all 360 had in online gaming and more, then I'd probably own a PS3, so exclusives do not draw me from one to another - plus I tend to like the 360 game selection a bit better too) then that is obviously a big reason for picking on over another

Quote:

Originally Posted by pedrohead

plus it seems like some of the technological advantages of the ps3 (1080p gaming, capabilities for 7 controllers, HDMI ports, built in wireless, 7.1/true-HD sound, etc.) may make it a little more technologically sound and future proof for a few more years.

So many people talk about this and believe me - I'm very technical and love technology.. its what I do - I'm a network consultant - heck, I have more servers at home than many of my clients

But.. I think Sony was really just aiming for selling people on numbers.. 1080P, 7, 7.1...etc. Let's break it down:

1080P - As we have learned in this forum, 1080i looks just as good as 1080P on a good 1080P set. Plus, from a gaming standpoint, very few games will be released in 1080P. Think of the processing power..etc needed for 1080P. 720P looks amazing and is the best balance for developers. With 1080P, you MUST sacrifice something, whether it be framerate, textures..etc.

7 - 7 Controllers!?!? First, how many people own 7 controllers? Are you going to buy 7? 2nd - How many people enjoy split screen with 2 people? How about 4? Ok.. consider trying it with ... yes.. 7! This is such a gimmick... Only thing it would be useful for is games like football where everyone is visible on one screen (or soccer.. you get the idea). So.. educate me please. Do any PS3 games support 7 players like this? Do any even support 7 player split screen?

7.1 - This may just be me, because I'm not an audiophile - I love my 5.1, but in my space, 7.1 would be wasted. And in fact, I think its wasted in many spaces. I'd even be willing to bet that if you played at my house in 5.1 and then went home to 7.1, you'd be hard pressed to tell the difference.

Wifi - This I can agree with - its great to have it built in. BUT, keep in mind it does affect the cost of the console. So for those that don't need it, its added cost and it goes unused. I just used my old wireless adapter that my xbox used.

Quote:

Originally Posted by pedrohead

i may be looking at a 360 before that time comes, but i really only want to get one console. i don't play too much (and don't really play online), so i'm keeping my options open.

Can I ask why you don't play online? Don't like it? Too much trouble with the PS2 version??

And I ask because it amazes me. Playing online is the single most important aspect a game can have in my opinion. Bomberman for the 360 was given terrible reviews and most people hated it. I had rented it and it was awesome to play online. I have yet to find any game that isn't fun to play online and its awesome to see a "friend" pop up (I use quotes because I really don't know these people

) and then join them in a game.

EDIT - You left out one thing. Bluetooth. This I actually like. Assuming I could use my verizon bluetooth headset, I think this was a cool addition.

mshulman · 12-10-2006, 06:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bboncorr

true-hd sound is available on both systems. ms will be releasing a hdmi soon based on there recent update so that wont be a advantage either. component will give you the same quality video as hdmi so dont buy into the hype.

Do you have any info on the hdmi? Everything I've seen just indicates rumours.

Personally I could care less - its not needed in my opinion. It would allow me to make use of the cable I have run to my projector, but hardly necessary at this point. Only when the copy protection gets turned on (or preferably a few months before) do I feel it would be necessary.

I must say, its very nice to see some actually conversation going back and forth on features instead of just bashing one company over the other.. Still interesting that we haven't heard from a few people....

12-10-2006, 12:17 PM	#1
mshulman My Projector is High Def. Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: Marlborough, MA Age: 35 Posts: 6,767	Why are you getting or did you get a PS3 over a 360? I'm curious about this and haven't really gotten any replies when I've approached the subject in other threads. So.. If you are only buying 1 console, why did you choose the PS3? I'd also be interested in those that have sold 360's to get a PS3. All I see for advantages are: Bluray or compatibility with PS2 games/accessories. Other than that, I think 360 offers everything else, PLUS great online gaming. Maybe PS3 owners don't rank online play as high as I do??

12-10-2006, 12:26 PM	#2
Type A 1080 Optical Supporter Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Panama City, Fl Age: 38 Posts: 2,723	LOL, wrong forum dude...try this one: http://www.ps3forums.com/ Sorry, I know its a smart ass remark, but couldnt resist...and I think this forum is just a little pro-M$ __________________ Mitsubishi HC3000U HD projector Dual Optoma 106" screens Harman Kardon AVR-7000 receiver Bose 901 VI, 301 IV, VCS 10 Bose AM-6 Series III Sony STR-DG600 receiver JVC GR-HD1 HD camcorder Xbox 360 Pro / PS3 40 Gig HD DVD 0 / Blu Ray 15 Games 18 / Games 2 Gateway 901x HTPC (modified) Sling Box Pro w/HD Connect Cable Dish 211 receiver w/Absolute HD pack HP Pavilion dv-6000 laptop (HTPC2GO) Link-Theater Gallery - 100,000+ views Link-55 Restoration Updated 6/21/08

12-10-2006, 04:04 PM	#6
Razor05 HD = 65 beautiful inches Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: Canada Posts: 3,456	I think one of the biggest deciding factors is Xbox Live. If you feel that both consoles are about the same, and you love playing online, then the choice is simple. If there is one thing that Sony can't compare to, it would be that. __________________ Panasonic TH-65PZ850U Sony KDL37XBR6 Panasonic TH-37PX50U Cambridge Audio Azur 640R & 740C Paradigm Studio 60's, 20's, CC-590 & Seismic 12 Panasonic DMP-BD35 Toshiba HD-XA2 & A35 Motorola VIP1200 Monster HTFS1000, PB2100 Audio Authority 1154a MW2 LE & Halo3 LE Xbox 360 + HD-DVD GT: Razor59 Sony PS3 slim GT:Razor_59 Sony PSP

Similar Threads to Why are you getting or did you get a PS3 over a 360?
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Why should I get a PS3?	PokeFanGw	Blu-Ray Players	15	12-12-2008 04:58 AM
Why Are You Buying/NOT Buying Blu-ray/DVD movies	cheezz	High Definition Media	130	12-06-2008 09:11 AM
Why are there so few viewing this forum now?	GLOW	Gaming & Systems	34	07-28-2008 01:09 AM
Why do you think Sony will ruin HDM?	iDarren	High Definition Media	70	01-10-2008 02:29 AM
PS3: Drake's (un)Fortune with sales	Cygnus	Gaming & Systems	137	01-06-2008 10:37 AM
Why do HD-DVD fanboys believe they will win the format war?	Badlander 73	HD DVD Players	119	09-01-2007 04:00 PM

12-10-2006, 02:20 PM	#4
Steve44 Super Moderater Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Washington D.C. metropolitan area Age: 28 Posts: 1,045	Personally, I feel both consoles are about the same right now in terms of graphics. I'm only looking for basic online play - both offer that for free. I want to use a high-definition dvd. Both have that for same price - essentially. However, the PS3 offers HDMI which is a plus (I think) - not a negative (PS3 +0.5) I owned and loved PS2 games more than Xbox games (GTA is my absolute favorite game ever. (PS3 +1). I can also play my other PS2 games that I own on my PS3 because I'm not done playing those. Then I can sell my used ps2 for $25 (PS3 +0.5) I also still feel (or maybe I'm just hopelessly hoping) that the PS3 will only improve. (PS3 +0.5) I can watch HD video clips from the internet (PS3 +0.5) HD-DVD may win the format war in a few years and then the BluRay options will decrease (360 +1.0) I can put music on my PS3 and listen to the music on my surround sound (PS3 +0.5) (I really don't know if 360 can do that - haven't heard about it). I think there are a few other things, but that's a decent list... For me PS3 wins by 2.5pts (not much) on my personal weighted scale. I may be a fanboy now but I wasn't a few months ago. I started with wanting to buy a PS3 and then was going to pick up the 360 for about 2 weeks, but then I decided to stick with the PS3. Besides, what-ever console I buy will be free because of gift cards and my "SPIFF" money from work.

12-10-2006, 03:35 PM	#5
pjc High Definition is the definition of life. Join Date: Oct 2006 Posts: 2,123	When I get mine, I will get a 360. I was a PS fanboy having the PS1 and PS2. Two of my buddies both got original XBOX's. Wanting to be able to play against them online, I traded my PS2 in for any XBOX (~4-5 years ago.). I have NEVER regretted it. I liked the XBOX much better. I am going to stick with M$ because I liked the original XBOX over the PS2 and the 360 out of the box is cheaper. I know, if you add the 360' HD-DVD drive, their the same price. Well, I may or may upgrade, but I have the choice.

12-10-2006, 04:56 PM	#7
Steve44 Super Moderater Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Washington D.C. metropolitan area Age: 28 Posts: 1,045	Agree, if you want all that in online play. 360 online is far better and I think most will agree. But other than online play, PS3 offers more of what I would use. Basic online play is good enough for me.

12-10-2006, 05:52 PM	#9
pedrohead High Definition is the definition of life. Join Date: Sep 2005 Posts: 110	i haven't bought either yet, but am looking into the options. i have a ps2 (as far as previous console) and really enjoy some of the ps-proprietary games like metal gear, gran turismo, ssx, so that would really steer me toward ps3. plus it seems like some of the technological advantages of the ps3 (1080p gaming, capabilities for 7 controllers, HDMI ports, built in wireless, 7.1/true-HD sound, etc.) may make it a little more technologically sound and future proof for a few more years. but i think it may be months (or another year) before it really gets its footing and gets some good games under its belt. i may be looking at a 360 before that time comes, but i really only want to get one console. i don't play too much (and don't really play online), so i'm keeping my options open.