High Def Forum
Thank you for visiting. This is our website archive. Please visit our main website by clicking the logo above.

Is 3-D the New CinemaScope?

Lee Stewart
09-10-2008, 04:30 PM
Is 3-D the New CinemaScope?

July 25, 2008

Families scurried to their closest picture show in the early part of the 20th century to watch the very latest movie or indulge in Saturday serial matinees and marathons. They had no choice at the time as this was the only means to enjoy the then burgeoning form of visceral entertainment.

In the 1950's, a little invention called the television set ignited a paradigm shift in how moviegoers were able to access entertainment. For the first time, they were able to stay at home to "view" a show and thus were apt to visit theaters less frequently. Theaters, in turn, lost money to the magical little black-and-white set-top box.

Hollywood was forced to scramble for a new means to lure patrons back into theaters so they turned their attention towards new technologies and innovations. Debuting in 1953 was a flick titled The Robe that was filmed with a new technology dubbed CinemaScope, i.e. a never-before-seen widescreen format no television at the time could replicate. It didn’t take long for moviegoers to catch onto the new craze and fill theaters once again with the promise of a captivating CinemaScope presentation.

Flash forward 30 years into the 1980s and home video was vying to steal a chunk of box office receipts. Moviegoers could leave their shoes in the closet and stay at home to watch films on VHS, but not in the cinematic widescreen format. That is, until laserdisc arrived on the scene introducing the first letterbox titles. But consumers felt cheated by the black bars above and below the picture that "shrunk" their beloved films to a size smaller than their TV sets. Theaters retained the upper hand while laserdisc fought a losing battle to escape the confines of a niche audience.

It wasn't until the Digital Video Disc, or DVD, debuted in the late 1990s when consumers were granted an option of viewing films at home in either widescreen or full-screen. This "weaning effect" brought renewed interest to home video and turned previous widescreen naysayers into believers. Naturally box office receipts gradually declined as more and more moviegoers turned towards DVD rentals and purchases for their movie fixes.


Today, DVD continues to flourish albeit with reduced growth, and new players like Blu-ray Disc, video-on-demand and streaming video via the Internet are keeping moviegoers out of theaters more than ever. What has happened before will happen again, and Hollywood is turning towards an already proven and delicately refined technology to offer an exclusive draw its internal competition cannot.

The theatrical release of Journey to the Center of the Earth earlier this summer marks the return of 3-D filmmaking on a grand scale after The Nightmare Before Christmas was converted into 3-D and re-released late last year. Other catalog films like all six Star Wars entries, George A. Romero's classic Dawn of the Dead and Pixar's Toy Story films are being converted to 3-D as well. More importantly, studios such as Disney have stated all their future animated projects will be shot in 3-D.

Despite being around for several decades, Hollywood is touting 3-D as the new "best thing" in hopes moviegoers won't want to pass up the chance to experience a film in a way they cannot while parked on a couch at home. 3-D hopes to be the new CinemaScope that turns the tide to theaters' advantage once again.

Business and technology moves at a much faster pace than it did in the 1950's and although 3-D has yet to saturate a growing number of digital cinemas that support it, the Society of Motion Picture and Television Engineers have already created a task force to research and report on what it will take to bring 3-D into homes via the Internet, Cable, Satellite and Blu-ray Disc. 3-Ds existence as an exclusive cinematic experience is poised to be short lived.

We have all come a long way from air conditioned theaters, Sunday matinees, the first widescreen film and the introduction of the home theater concept. 3-D may be walking in the footsteps of CinemaScope at the box office, but today's climate necessitates theaters and home video work in harmony for the filmmaking industry to thrive as a whole. What works for one should work for the other whether it be 10-channel surround sound, 3-D, motion-coded chairs and so on. The days of a technology drawing a line between one medium and the next have been forever blurred.

When you pick up your favorite Blu-ray Disc film in the not-too-distant future, you might have to contemplate selecting the 2-D or 3-D version to watch. Makes you wonder what's going to surface next, doesn't it?

- Darrin Stock
http://www.thehdroom.com/news/Is_3-D_the_New_CinemaScope/3156

rbinck
09-10-2008, 07:49 PM
I wonder if Journey was also available in the color 3D as well as the polarity version. I don't think the polarity tech will work on many home sets.

97XBAM
09-20-2008, 02:47 PM
I saw a Mitsubishi factory demonstration of DLP 3D which uses battery powered shutter glasses . Didn't last long enough to give any eyestrain , which I had after viewing Journey To The Center Of The Earth(it felt like my eyes were crossing at times) - but it's possible the theater did something wrong , since I had no feeling of my eyes crossing during the movie or headache/eyestrain after watching Beowulf last year . Or maybe that Real D 3D tech just works better with animated movies . In any case Real D made a deal with Regal theaters to equip 1500 theaters in 2009 for 3D . Which is why James Cameron pushed back his 3D sci-fi flick Avatar to December 2009 to get it in the maximum amount of theaters .

Real D is still like watching through sunglasses . If they ever develop 3D with real lifelike color , minus the eyestrain -that's the 3D that will take the medium to mass market acceptance . Well , mine anyway .

bmore
09-24-2008, 08:26 PM
Panasonic to Display 3D Blu-ray Technology at CEATEC

Posted September 24, 2008 04:22 PM by Josh Dreuth

Panasonic At the upcoming CEATEC show in Japan, Panasonic will be displaying 3D technology based on the Blu-ray format. Officially, the Blu-ray Disc Association (BDA) has not approved a single method for Blu-ray use, but Panasonic hopes that their display will convince those parties involved to select their method.

The method requires the viewer to wear synchronized shuttered glasses that will differentiate between the two simultaneous 1080p images sent to the display. The Blu-ray disc stores both video encodes on the same disc, and decodes both images at the same time. The result is a surprisingly life-like 3D experience.

Hollywood is in a full on sprint to get 3D into the movie theaters, forcing electronics manufacturers to figure out a way to get the experience into the home. The Blu-ray format is seen as the best possible way of doing that with its massive data storage and bandwidth properties.
http://www.blu-ray.com/news/?id=1819

Sounds cool. No more red/blu glasses...but two different encodes.