I just voted for VOOM. While I have Comcast HD, even the slightest amount of research has to give the nod to VOOM. I also like the fact that they are using a lower compression algorithm. I had DirecTV for a while and it was totally unwatchable in SD. The pixelation was off the radar screen! I understand that "Dish" is a bit better but VOOM is the champ. My next move will probably be to VOOM.