View Single Post
Old 06-26-2006, 08:16 PM   #15
rockaway1836
High Definition is the definition of life.
 

Join Date: May 2005
Location: Myrtle Beach SC
Posts: 1,035
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by PFC5
The reason that he stated this about using the Component output is because Bill Hunt of The Digitalbits (seems to be a BD supporter) has taken back his poor review of the Samsung. We can all speculate WHY, but he says it is because most of the problems are with the HDMI output. None of the indepth reviewers/testers that are well know (from Secrets Benchmark, etc) has seen the miraculous improvement using component that Bill Hunt has seen.

But the Samsung can actually it can go as high as 1080i (not p) over Samsung's component output with a BD movie, but it will only do 480p using component with a SD DVD movie. There is no upscaling over component output with SD DVDs per the DVD Forum specs. Some Chinese mfg of SD DVD players have ignored this, but Samsung is following the SD DVD spec.

I think what you are talking about is AACS (not HDCP only used on digital connections), which allows (per the studio's demands) something called ICT, which COULD cut the resolution to 960x540 IF the studio implements it on any movie discs. None have so far but they could without notice.

One of the problems with the Samsung BD player is it was originally a 1080i maximum output device, but when BDA started the "1080p is 'true HD'" campaign to cloud the issue with this proven red herring, Samsung decided to add it into their "after the design fact".

This is causing the Samsung to take the 1080p/24Fps data on the movie discs and the original design converts it to 1080i, then the Mickey Mouse after thought design (using the after thought Faroudja chip) brings it back 1080p.

The Samsung is broken on many levels, but the most noticable problem is the BD movie discs currently released themselves. Samsung is falling on the sword for Sony since Sony delayed their own BD player release AGAIN to "On or about 10/25/06". Funny how the inventor of the technology will not even have a player out until 4 months AFTER the format debuts.
No doubt about it, this debut is not helping Sony, Samsung, or Blu-Ray in general. I just wish they didn't rush these things to market before they were ready for prime time. I'm not just talking abut Samsung and Sony here. Toshiba was a bit quick on the trigger with their's as well. The good thing is we have forums like this to share info on what's going on. Although sometimes I wonder what motivates some to just slam whichever company they don't happen to like. Some people hate Sony others hate Microsoft. Why? I don't know. And I don't really care. It just makes it a bit harder to sift through the BS and get to the truth.
On a side note I do have a little info to pass on. I got a call today from Samsung. They were following up on the 1080P HDMI handshake issue that I reported to them late last week. The gentleman I spoke with told me thet were going to have a meeting today about this problem and try to figure out a solution. He could not however, give me a time frame for a fix.
rockaway1836 is offline   Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links